आज जिस विषय पर मैं लिखने जा रहा हूँ, संभवतः वह समय की धारा के अनुकूल कतई नहीं, प्रतिकूल अवश्य है. मैने समाजवादी दल से अपने निष्कासन के बाद सदैव अपने पुराने दल के नए प्रवक्ता मोहन की गालियाँ सुनी और उसे भी ढेरों सुनाई. अन्ना हजारे जी का बयान कि राजनेताओं को चील कौवों के हवाले कर दो. सुश्री उमा भारती और श्री ओमप्रकाश चौटाला को अपमानित कर भगा दो, क्योंकि ये नेता है. इस परिपेक्ष्य में समाजवादी प्रवक्ता मोहन का बयान कि ऐसा करके राजनीति को लांछित और राजनेताओं को मात्र चोर कह भर देने से कोई आमूल चूल परिवर्तन देश में नहीं आ पाएगा, यह एक सराहनीय बयान है. क्या अन्ना गाँधी से बड़े है? गांधी जी ने कहा था कि पाप से घृणा करो पापी से नहीं. यदि अन्ना की नजर में पापी चौटाला जी और उमा जी उनकी शरण में शुद्ध होने पहुँच गए, तो बुराई क्या थी? वाल्मिकी जी “मरा मरा” कहते कहते “राम राम” तक पहुंचे और रामायण तक लिख डाली और दस्युराज “अंगुलीमाल” जो लोगों के क़त्ल के बाद उनके शरीर की अँगुलियों की माला पहनता था, उसे भी भगवान बुद्ध ने शरणागत होने पर शरण दे दी थी. लोकनायक जयप्रकाश और आचार्य विनोबा भावे ने भी तमाम डाकुओं का आत्मसमर्पण कराया था. क्या अन्ना बुद्ध, गांधी, जे.पी. और विनोबा से भी बड़े हो गए जो अपने आन्दोलन का समर्थन करने आए नेताओं का तिरस्कार करवा डाला.
बाबा रामदेव के निकट के एक सज्जन मेरे पास हो सकता है स्वान्तः सुखाय मुझे निमंत्रित करने पहुंचे. एक बार मन हुआ चले, फिर सोचा क्या पता मुझे भी चौटाला और उमा ना बनाना पड़े. एक साथ देश भर में मोमबत्तियों का जलना, धरना, प्रदर्शन, नरेन्द्र मोदी जी और एन.डी.ए. के ही नितीश जी की तारीफ़ और फिर आदरणीय अडवानी जी का अन्ना को खुला समर्थन, परिवारवाद का विवाद आन्दोलन के शुरुआती चरण में, रामदेव जी और किरण बेदी की समिति में नदारदी, अन्ना समर्थक देश के कई युवाओं के मन को उद्वेलित करती है. यदि क़ानून का ही मसला था तो शांतिभूषण जी के बेटे प्रशांत की जगह काले धन की लड़ाई सुप्रीम कोर्ट में लड़ने वाले राम जेठमलानी जी को लाया जा सकता था. नेता, उद्योगपति और भ्रष्टाचार से इतनी ही नफ़रत है तो १९७७ की प्रथम जनता पार्टी के पदाधिकारियों की सूची देखें- अध्यक्ष श्री मोरारजी देसाई, महासचिव- श्री लालकृष्ण अडवानी, श्री रामधन,श्री विजय सिंह नाहर, श्री रामकृष्ण हेगड़े और कोषाध्यक्ष-श्री शांति भूषण. मोरारजी के कोषाध्यक्ष शांति भूषण जी और उस समय मोरारजी के सुपुत्र कान्ति देसाई अपने उद्यम, छवि, और काम-काज के लिए काफी मशहूर थे. बजाय आवाज उठाने के श्री शांति भूषण जी आप पहले कोषाध्यक्ष फिर मोरारजी भाई के क़ानून मंत्री भी बन गए थे. मै नहीं कहता कि कांति भाई गलत थे, वह सही रहे होंगे. पर फिर इतना जरूर पूछूँगा कि यदि कांति भाई सही, रंजन भट्टाचार्य भाई सही तो कोई और गलत क्यूँ? शुचिता और शुद्धता, नैतिकता और मर्यादा मात्र आप और आपके परिवार के बेटों का एकाधिकार क्यों?
“यार हमारी बात सुनो, ऐसा एक इंसान चुनो, जिसने पाप ना किया हो, जो पापी ना हो”. अन्ना जी संघर्ष करो, सिर्फ शांति भूषण जी, प्रशांत भैया, नरेन्द्र मोदी जी, नितीश जी ही नहीं सोनिया जी और मनमोहन जी भी आपके साथ है और इसीलिये तो श्री कपिल सिब्बल से गजटेड आर्डर लेते ही स्वामी अग्निवेश जी ने सोनिया जी और मनमोहन जी को धन्यवाद कह दिया था. आन्दोलन के अगले चरण की प्रतीक्षा रहेगी निशाने पर न्यायमूर्ति , अफसर, उद्योगपति कौन होंगे? क्योंकि अन्ना जी भ्रष्टाचार सिर्फ नेताओं में नहीं हर जगह है. श्री बालाकृष्णन जी चर्चा में है, यह सज्जन नेता नहीं है, बलवा और यूनिटेक के चंद्रा और मद्रासी शिवशंकर भी चर्चा में है, यह भी नेता नहीं है, और आज ही आपके महाराष्ट्र के हाईकोर्ट ने इनकम टैक्स के बड़े अधिकारी एस.सी. टेकवानी की चोरी पकड़ी है, यह भी नेता नहीं है. भ्रष्टाचार अपने शबाब पर यत्र, तत्र, सर्वत्र है और इसके प्रासंगिक निराकरण का सूझ-बूझ का बयान राजस्थान के मुख्यमंत्री श्री अशोक गहलोत जी का है कि जब तक चुनावों में लक्ष्मी मैया की कृपा के अंत की प्रक्रिया पारदर्शिता से लागू करने हेतु चुनावों की “स्टेट फंडिंग” नहीं होगी, कुछ नहीं हो सकता है. इस बयान से मै भी सहमत हूँ.
अंतिम बात, मुझे शरद पवार जी या उनकी राजनीति या उनके दल से कुछ लेना-देना नहीं, आपकी नजर में वह बहुत बुरे है, लेकिन बारामती के लोगों से भी तो ज़रा पूंछो, कि शरद पवार कैसे है? तथाकथित भ्रष्टाचार में डूबे हुए हर नेता का कम से कम एक बारामती तो है लेकिन समाज की अन्य विधाओं में उच्च पदों पर बैठे भ्रष्टाचाररत न्यायमूर्ति, पत्रकार, अफसर, उद्योगपति सिर्फ एकतरफा लेते है देने का कोई उपक्रम उनके पास नहीं है. कुछ भी हो कम से कम भ्रष्टाचार आपके कारण बहस का मुद्दा तो बना पर यह लड़ाई नेतागिरी तक चयनात्मक ना हो बल्कि समाज के सभी वर्गों में व्याप्त भ्रष्टाचार के विरुद्ध सामूहिक संघर्ष हो तो मै भी एक टोपी सिलवाकर, उस पर यह लिख कर कि “मै भी अन्ना हजारे हूँ” आपका जयकारा करूंगा.
पैसे का महत्त्व राजनीति में इतना हो गया है कि असम में तृणमूल सांसद के.डी. सिंह पकडे जाते है और रुपया पकडे जाने पर भी छोड़ने के लिए चुनाव आयोग को आयकर विभाग के अधिकारियों के विरुद्ध कार्यवाही का निर्देश देना पड़ता है. चेन्नई में भी चुनावी दौर में भारी नकदी पकड़ी जाती है. यह हाल तृणमूल ऐसे दल से सम्बद्ध दल का है जिसकी नेता ममता बनर्जी की ईमानदारी पर अब तक प्रश्न नहीं हुआ है. ख़ैर आदरणीय हजारे जी की नजर में सबसे बड़े ईमानदार पिता-पुत्र की जोड़ी आदरणीय श्री शान्ति भूषण जी और श्री प्रशांत भूषण जी को ढेरों बधाइयां. उम्मीद है यह जोड़ी कुछ न कुछ हलचल तो जरूर करेगी.
very soon u will be eager to meet me Mr. Amar singh
Hi,
I am in total agreement with your opinion.
How can only Father-Son could be only honest. Why not RamDev Ji Maharaj and Kiran Bedi in the team. People with same origin, region and family can not be considered as only leaders against corruption. with this decision as if anna ji wants to tell all honesty was born in Bhushan & Family.
Anna Ji should think about weakness of same origin politics. why is anna ji not trying to improve his own place from regional discrimination i.e. marathi & non-marathi, this is equally dangerous for our nation.
-Ved
Today leaders from different parties coming together to oppose Anna, what a politics.
This is very good planing.
At least pakde jaane per kaha jaa sakta hai…I oppose Anna that’s why I am in Jail.
People from baramati, saifai, amethi etc may ignore but rest of India watching it closely.
Anna always says if corruption can’t be stopped but we should try to reduce it. In todays time majority of politicians, bureaucrats, never thing twice to be label as corrupt. They don’t fear to go to Jail in lack of strong law.
-Vinay
you are right amar ji
aapse ye ummid thi, aap biprit bayan denge anna ke.
Amar Singh ji, I agree with your views that corruption today is not only limited to politicians and seeped into every sphere of life. But if anyone is trying to make a positive impact in its eradication, why criticize hime and the good people around him.
You have done good support for the cause of creation of Poorvanchal, which is laudable, but we would like to see your polity on a positive footprint, rather than negative.
Ravi, Dublin, Ireland
ठाकुर साहब आपने अकरक्ष एकदम सही लिखा है इसमें कोई दो राइ नहीं की सभी नेता भ्रष्ट नहीं है और इस कमेटी के सभी लोग देवता नहीं हैं
Anna hazare only advocating Lok Pal Bill which is already proposed in 1972. Since then politicians and some are trying to neglect the bill to suit thier theft. That’s why anna ji is fighting for. I believe if we want to save our country we need to catch big fish first.
I am in total agree with your views and have already expressed my views regarding, Gandhiji never have abused any , but have to try to implant the faith in ones heart towards the vlaue living and changed the heart of people, have ask them to raised their tolerence at the cost of their life, at that time also all kind of corruption was there but in absence of any effecctive print and electronic media it never highlited the way it comes in light today, Anna has no right to abuse any one, Anna has right to demand, can encouraged and motivate to divert the people towards value oriented thinking and living but he has no right even for his reception for which he commented that he recieved even bigger garlanded reception in his village then previous one, I think people are India once again has been cheated by other leader, today I there is progress witnessing India, it is thanks to the Leaders – what ever quality – but without the leaders it is not possible, this is systemic failure , we have to take the step to make the system work effective, and that is not possible by abusing the leaders who are not aliens but they are from within our society , part of our society, let teach every one to respect the rights of others , respect the selfrespect of others , Anna has no right to insult , yes this Govt is sensitive and postivly responsevive towards the corrouption, and in case of Dr. if there was any other PM like Lalu or Mulayam or Charansinh or Mayawati even Fool Nitin then Anna whould have not dare to go on fast until death, but I think he must have full faith in the genriosity of Dr. Manmohansinji or else the result could have been otherwise , though the cause he has taken was right his style is totally totally unagreeable
Very well said sir. Atleast i am very happy that i am a follower of such a leader that he has the guts to say what is absolutely true. Regards
शायद आप को अभी तक यह अहसास नहीं हो पाया है की आम आदमी के उपर क्या बीत रही है ब्रहष्टचार की वजह से. अगर गेर नेता लोग corrupt हैं तो यह कोई justificaiton नहीं है नेता का corrupt होना. बात आन्ना हज़ारे की नहीं है. बात है ब्र्ाष्टाचार की. नेता का कार्य है ब्रसटाचार को रोकना ना की खुद ब्रष्ट बन जाना.
leader hi hamare Desh ka nayak hota hai na..? agar woh bhrashtachaari ban jaye to vyapari, nyayamurti, naukershah ka bhrashta hona aasaan ho jata hai ! sirf hazare ko nahin, janshakti ke umde gusse ko samajhne ki koshish karen aur rai den ki bhrashtachaar ko rajneeti se kaise door kiya jaye…!
साठ के अंतिम तथा सत्तर के दशक के शुरू में – ” नौकरी की तनख्वाह के अलावा लड़के को थोड़ी बहुत ऊपर से भी कमाई हो जाती है ” की तरह के statement को समाज के भिन्न वर्गों ने जिस सहजता से न सिर्फ स्वीकार किया बल्कि दबे स्वर में उसको promote भी किया , वह आज एक रक्तबीज राक्षस की तरह हर तरफ निरंतर पैदा हो रहा है | कुछ डरपोक किस्म के कमज़ोर दब्बुओं को छोड़कर जिनके पास कोई रास्ता भ्रष्ट होने का नही है , सारा समाज आज छाती ठोककर खुले आम भ्रष्टाचार में लिप्त है | लोगों ने जल्दी ही समझ लिया कि अगर ईमानदारी का ढोल पीटते रहे तो सिवा पिछड़ने और सारी आधुनिक सुविधाओं से वंचित रहने के सिवा कोई नियति नही बची | रही सही कसर नेताओं, सरकारी महकमों और उनमे नियुक्त बेशर्म नौकरशाहों ने पूरी कर दी | चाहे वो पुलिस हो या फिर कोई और महकमा |
अन्ना का संघर्ष यदि साठ के दशक में शुरू होता तो सफलता निश्चित थी | अब मामला हाथ से निकल गया दिखता है क्योंकि भ्रष्टाचार के साथ समाज की आत्मा ने समझौता कर लिया है | अब यह मन की उहापोह की स्थिति से बहुत गहरे अन्दर तक स्थापित हो गया है |
Dr. Dinesh Sharma
Hi Amar Sing , Main ye to nahi kahta ki sirf neta ho choar hain magr neta sabse bade choar hain jinki chamdi kafi moti hai . aur ye itne besarm hai ki inke upar koi arop lago inhe koi fark nahi padta.janta ka paisa kha -2 kar ye itne besarm ho chuke hain ki anaaa jaise dewata insana ko is jung main ana pada. kripya ek bhale vakyti ka apman mat karen aur janta ki bhawan ko samjhe . ishwar sabhi neta longo ko sach ke marg par chalne ki shakti de
Balwa and Chandra are there because Raja was willing to favour them by taking cut. If the politicians are not corrupt and accountability is there more than 50% of problem will get solved.
I don’t think Anna Hazare is against all politician, he never said that and in fact he apologised for Uma Bharti incident.
It’s the politician irrespective of party line who are more worried with this bill, else why it was never given priority in 42 years and Anna had to go on fasts.
Dear Amar Singhji,
Again marvellous column.
Even i have doubted that why both BHUSHAN (father and son)are in the committee. It would have been more better if Ram Jethmalani would have been in the committee, the person who is also fighting for the Black money , But ANNA is suspecious on this both part. Again Anna should reply to nation why he didn’t raise his voice against black money or why he din’t force the govt to reveal the name of the tax evader who illegaly snip off the money in LICHTENSTINE BANK, GERMANY. i want to raise the issue if Anna is so much eager for social justice for the citizen of india, then where he was when the wild boar of Raj Thackrey mishandelled people from north india. What was Anna doing when our national language was insulted in Maharastra again by coward Raj Thackray. Can Anna or any of his support reply to me.
Anyway a heartiest thanks for your valuable suggestion. Sir don’t mind but i want to see your column in all leading national as well as regional newspaper. Please tie up with newspaper and do so if possible.
Regards,
Rahul Deo Singh
Bahut khoob,kya likha hai bade bhai nai.
Dear Amar,
Why are you so worried about Anna Hajare’s movement?
No one pointed your name at all. If you are clean then do continue in your own way. If you really want to remove corruption, there are so many ways, you can do.
Please leave Anna Hajare….. at least for GOD .
Regards,
Vinit
Amar Singh G namaskar aap ka lakh aacha laga mai ek baat kanha chahata hon ke is dash mai jisa moka nahi mila who imandar hai varna jis desh mai har election mai ticket bikta hon whan par imandari kee umeed karna nasamji hai aap ka apna B.S.CHAWLA NEW DELHI
Sh. Anna Hazare is playing with fire.The system may have many shortcommings. This is the system which is making people gather at Janter Mantar and revolt and there is redressal of thir problems also.This is the system which says and listens too. If common man specially youth, looses faith in the system then Sh. Anna hazare has no alternative system.Calling every one corrupt is very easy but identifiying corrupt people supporting them is very difficult.Is every body today gathering at jantar mantar or using social network sites honest.No, no bobody can generalise. We can not brand any one corrupt only because he is an officer or politician.If we do this then Sh. Anna Hazare will also be judged by his own followers like Baba Ramdev and many others.
Sir,
No not the politicians only but their leiutenanats are also chips of the same block. I went to the office of a Dalit leader living at 12 Janpath, New Delhi till recently. He was from Bihar. His PA asked me `Have you brought something?’ I said no. The honest PA said after five minutes: “You are wasting your time.” When this Dalit leader became Communications Minister, a Dalit writer took me to his office on the first day at 10AM. We had gone there to congratulate him. The Dalit writer told me that the leader from Bihar had visitors. The Personal Assistant to the Minister, an IAS officer, was surrounded by money bags at 10 AM. They had come to make their offerings and it was not the right time for us to meet him. We came back without meeting the Dalit leader.
nother example: I went to the office of the
Vigilance Officer, Room No;54, Old Secretariat, Delhi to lodge a complaint against MCD officials in response to an advt. in The Hindu saying that anyone could lodge a report against any department of MCD or Delhi govt in case of harassment. The Viugilsance, Pradip Hota by name, was sleeping in his office at 10AM. I waited for two hours but the officer did not wake up. His staff did not allow me to talk to him on phone or intercom. They did not accept my complaint also. I submitted the complaint with the office of the Police Commissioner next day. This is the state of affairs in Delhi, the capital of corruption.
A.L.Rawal
Since your are also the politician so I am not astonished that you must be feeling bad that no politicians got the opportunity to shared the dais with Anna or the public did not allow the politicians in this worthy and noble cause. So, I think as an Indian citizen you can feel the anger and anxiety of Indian common people about corruption. I do not know how the politicians have got this idea that Anna is against the Politico fraternity while he and his followers only talk about the corruptions (as you said different departments and different people are involved).
What I believe, why Anna and his followers did not allow the politicians there because every party used this opportunity to blame others so as a whole that was a good move. See, now all the parties are united in not supporting the Anna. And if anybody wants to associated with this movement so s/he could resign and join.
I will give an example here, he just praised Nitish and Modi see the statement of Digi Raja and yours as well as you said both belongs to NDA. You mean to say that if they are doing well but belongs to NDA so should not be praised.
I think you know better if Anna is praising someone so he must be praising for their good works not for the communal right.
And in last, by seeing the Kapli Sibbal statements (before and after the movement) the common people have big doubts and we are correct in our doubt as well.
SIR ,bas mujhe aap ye bataiye ki kya ek ANNA HAZARE jaise log is congress ka kya bigad sakate hai jhan KAPIL SIBBAL jaise neta roz apne bayan badal rahe hai.Mujhe to nhi lagata ki ye LOKPAL BILL parit ho payega…
माननीय अमर सिंह जी ऐसे माहौल में जहाँ हर वो इंसान जो व्यवस्था का दोहन कर हकदार का हक मार कर अपना घर भर रहा है और अन्ना अन्ना कर रहा है आपने एक साहसी लेख लिखा जिसके लिए आप बधाई के पात्र हैं इस देश में नेताओं को गली देना एक फैशन बन गया है मिलावटखोर, दुनिया में सबसे निक्कमे सरकारी मुलाजिम,पेशेवर समाज सेवी, मरीजों कि खाल उधेड़ने वाले डॉक्टर, उम्मीद से कहीं ज्यादा तनख्वाह पाने वाले मास्टर सब के सब नेताओं को चोर कहते हैं ये बात अलग है कि आम लोगों कि तकलीफों के लिए ये ही सबसे ज्यादा जिम्मेदार होते हैं लेकिन क्यां किसी में हिम्मत है की वो खुल कर किसी एक नेता को गाली दे सके. मायावती ,जयललिता, ममता,लालू, मुलायम सिंह,शरद पवार ,अजित सिंह,नवीन पटनायक ,नितीश कुमार ,देवेगौड़ा ,चौटाला , प्रकाश सिंह बादल और न जाने कितने और अगर ये तमाम नेता अपने समर्थकों को एक इशारा भर कर दें तो देश में हाहाकार मच जायेगा.रहा सवाल इस देश के स्वयम्भू हरीशचंद पत्रकारों का तो इनका असल रूप अगर जनता के सामने आ जाये तो इन्हें कही सर छिपाने की जगह नहीं मिलेगी दरसल राजनेताओं की सबसे बड़ी गलती रही है कि उन्होंने कभी आम जनता को समर्थ बनाने कि कोशिश नहीं की हिंदुस्तान दुनिया का अकेला ऐसा मुल्क है जहाँ आम आदमी लोकतंत्र के नाम पर ठगा जा रहा है अंग्रेजों ने हमारे वजूद को कुचलने के लिए जो भी नियम कायदे बने थे वो आज भी कायम है हर बात में अमेरिका की होड़ करते हैं लेकिन वहां की सी आज़ादी हमें हासिल है वहां हर कोई अपनी हिफाज़त के लिए शस्त्र रख सकता है लेकिन हमारे ज़बरदस्त जन विरोधी शस्त्र कानून है अमेरिका में नौकरी करने वाले हिन्दुस्तानी नौजवान गरीब हिंदुस्तानियों के खून पसीने की कमाई से मिली सब्सिडी से डॉक्टर, इंजीनियर बन खिदमत कर रहे हैं अमेरिका की और बात कर रहे हैं भ्रष्टाचार की. पचास सिपाहियों की भर्ती होती है पहुचते हैं ५० हज़ार चुने गए देशभक्त और बाकी ४९९५० अन्ना एंड पार्टी कहती है कि जन लोकपाल की चयन समिति में नोबेल पुरस्कार और मैग्सेसे पुरस्कार विजेता रहेंगे यानि अमर्त्य सेन , वी एस नायेपौल , किरण बेदी, अरविन्द केजरीवाल , अरुणा रॉय , संदीप पांडे मतलब ये की लोकतान्त्रिक भारत में विदेशी मान्यता प्राप्त बुद्धिजीवी आप जैसे नेताओं से बस एक ही निवेदन है की आम जनता को सशक्त बनाईए ना कि सिर्फ सरकारी मुलाजिमों और चालू चंट पेशेवर समाजसेवियों को
Oops …you are again to your old habits of deception and fraud. I am ashamed that I spent my time in last 6 months with your blog. You have shown your real face by criticizing the saint of India ..Shri Anna Hazare.
Dear Anu
It was not easy to give critical comments on Shri Anna Hazare. I am not criticizing his issue, all i wanted to say that let us not be selective about Politicians only. This move against corruption should look into all other sections of society which are as corrupt as any other. As far as your opinion about me is concerned, i truthfuly expresse my thoughts and you are also free to express yourself.
तो अमर सिंह जी, आप इंतज़ार करिये…सामूहिकता का…इन्तजार का फल मीठा होता है…लाइन छोटी-बड़ी मत खींचिए…भ्रष्टाचार कहाँ है, कहाँ नहीं…ये आप तरवां के आम आदमी से लेकर किसान, मजदूर, रिक्शेवाले, मोची, ज़मादार और लोकमंच के आम कार्यकर्त्ता से पूछिए वो भी बता देगा…पहल हुई है…तारीफ कीजिये…नहीं तो उंगली उठाना बहुत आसान है…आपका भ्रात्र प्रेम,पूर्वांचल प्रेम,क्षत्रिय प्रेम, माटी प्रेम सपा से निकाले जाने के बाद क्यूँ जागा…लेकिन हमने(जनता) आपको माफ़ किया…देर आयद दुरुस्त आयद…चलो अच्छे मिशन पे तो लगा है…और आप जानते हैं जिसकी जितनी ज़िम्मेदारी होती है…उसकी उतनी भागीदारी भी होती है…वैसे आप बहुत समझदार हैं…जय हिंद
भ्रष्टाचार क्यूँ होता है ? मेरी समझ में तीन कारणों से भ्रष्टाचार होता है,
पहला कारण – लोभ – जिसमें देने वाला और लेने वाला दोनों पक्ष कुछ ना कुछ फायदा लेने की दृष्टि से इसमें लिप्त होते हैं, टैक्स चोरी, स्टाम्प ड्यूटी की चोरी, लोन/अनुदान प्राप्ति, वोट संग्रह, आउट ऑफ़ टर्न त्वरित कार्य की अपेक्षा, किसी संस्थान में दाखिला, किसी सजा से छूट, इत्यादि (८०% इसी श्रेणी में आते हैं अतः दोनों पक्ष बराबरी के जिम्मेदार हैं)
दूसरा कारण – भय – पुलिस की ज्यादितियों से बचना, प्रभावशाली व्यक्तियों की कृपा हेतु, समाज कंटकों से बचने के लिए, समाज में अपना अनावश्यक प्रभाव बनाने या बनवाने के लिए
तीसरा कारण – राजनैतिक – इसमें ना सिर्फ व्यक्ति/ पार्टी वरन राज्य एवं राष्ट्र सरकारें भी लिप्त होती हैं चाहे वोह संयुक्त राष्ट्र में पद प्राप्ति के लिए, पार्टी के चंदे के लिए, हथियारों की डील के लिए, सरकार बचने के लिए हो |
मैं दावे के साथ कह सकता हूँ की जब तक भ्रष्ट्राचार दोनों पक्षों के फायदे का होता है उसपर पर्दा डाल दिया जाता है किन्तु जब फायदे के बटवारे पर मतान्तर हो जाता है तो उंगली उठाई जातीं है |
एक कडवी सच्चाई यह भी है की भ्रष्टाचार भारत और अन्य देशों में एक कैटालिस्ट का काम करता है और इससे कार्य संपन्न भी हो रहे हैं अगर यह टिप की श्रेणी रहे तो इसके पैमाने तय करके इसे अधिकारिक तौर पर मान्यता दे देनी चाहिए | यदि डर के डंडे से इसे हटा कर कार्य क्षमता को मार दिया जायेगा तो संभवतः प्रगति बाधित हो सकती है |
आदरनीय अन्ना हजारे साहिब का प्रयत्न काफी सराहनीय है किन्तु कुछ कानूनी संशोधनों से क्रियात्मक प्रक्रिया बदली जाने का प्रारम्भ तो हो सकता है किन्तु उनके पालन की कोई गारंटी नहीं मणि जा सकती है | आज के युग में जहाँ पेशेंस की निहायत कमी है वहां ऐसे कानूनी फेरबदल चलते काम में अडंगा लगने जैसे माने जायेंगे |
देवेन्द्र
Dear Sir,
First of all ,Anna sahab is not saying that he is Ghandhiji.So I think this will give you aview of your explanation of 1st paragraph.
Second thing I will put my viewthat at least we have moved and prople liked it.I am not sure the result, but a good start till best ending
Sir,
We don’t understand why you people are so much against Anna Hazare and keep writing against him.
You are/were in public life for so many years.Why don’t you give a solution for the corruption in the society. Who is stopping you from leading a movement.Come forward – all the people will support you.
If you feel judges, bureaucrats are also equally corrupt , then why don’t you file a PIL against them in any court – Who is stopping you. That should be your duty right ?
What makes you feel Anna Hazare is being funded and his source of funding ? Where is the fund required. Mind you Sir, even if just 1% of Indians voluntarily contribute Rs. 10/- each, the movement will have sufficient corpus fund !
Small request – if you can help fight against evils in the society, please come forward, else please resist from writing blogs with so much of pessimistic view.
Regards,
Dear Vimal, I understand your sentiments. Issue of corruption is so sensitive that it connects every one very easily. I agree that fight against corruption is need of hour but at the same time we need to be very thoughtfull while dealing with such issue. However I appreciate your sentiments.
Amar singh ji aap kahna kya chah rahe hain Az ek hi sawal hai ki desh ki halat aisi kyon hai.Aap aam adami ki halat se wakif nahi hain
AGAR NETA SUDHAR JAY TO IAS PCS ENGINEER DOCTOR SE CHAPRASI TAK SUDHAR JAYENGE
sir ji, gud evening ,aap bhi anna hajare ki tarah ek pehal ker sakte hain , lakin aap nahin karenge, why , aap jaisa budhjivi person agar medaan main hoga tou anna hajare ji ko more power milagi , aap ka friend , manoj sharma Agra
sir, ek baat aur we wishing your good health,
aapke vichaaron ko kya kahe sir.
brahmano mein kshatriyon si virta liye yadi parshuram hue the to kshatriyon mein brahmano si teevra baudhik kshamta aapke paas hai.
wase rajneeti mein vyapt bhrashtachaar netaon ki nahi aam aadami ki den hai.
rajneetik dal kai criminals ko ticket dete hain kyonki unme se kai jeetne ki prabal sambhavanaayen rakhte hain. kyonki us samay hamari janta bhrasht ya sadhu vyakti nahi jaatiwaad ya kshetrawaad par vote karti hai aur jab unhi ke chune ye neta avaidh maamlon mein lipt paye jate hain to inhe ek anna ki jaroorat hoti hai. yahi janta kabhi ram laher par to kabhi gujraat dango mein maanavdhrmi netaon ko haraakar ek vishisht dal ko satta mein pahuchhate hain. u.p. mein ram lahar tatha gujraat mein godhara kand mein kya hua kai anna hazaare swach chavi ke baad bhi haare.
ye baat kya anna ki samajh mein nahi aati aur wo ek maanavta virodhi mukhyamantri ko ‘vikas ki soch’ wale neta k roop mein pesh karte hain vah vikaas jo kai laashon ya kabron ke upar bana hai to kya koi aisa vikas uchit hai. is tarah se to anna twarit bhrashtachaar ke virodhi hain bhrashtachaar ke mool ke nahi.
yadi bhrashtachhar mitaana hai to uske mool ko samajhna hoga.
ganhiji ke sach ko samajhna hoga aur anna ek baar phir wo panktiyaan yaad karen “PAAP SE GHRINA KARO PAAPI SE NAHI”
Amarji,
1.Shayad Anna Bhrastachari Ped ko kaatane kee shuruaat jadon se karana chahate hon? Baaki sab to tahaniyaan, patte ityaadi hain jo collection aur transportation ka commission basis par kaam karate hain.
2.Jahaan tak change aane ka sawaal hain mujhe to koi khaash ummeed nahin hai…candles jal gayee, logon ne kuchh dinon tak hulladwaaji kar lee but sustainable change laane ke liye 4-5 din ka nahin Arab countries jaise lambe aandolan kee jaroorat hai….aur usake liye sirf ek Anna nahin Gandhi, Vinoba aur JP sab ikatthe ek saath chaahiye….aur shaayad saath main Bhagat aur Subhash bhee.
Regards
Vijay
Respected Sir,
Fully agree with your opinion.But as a true Indian Shri Anna Hazare should have come forward at the time when poor north indian were beaten up by MNS goondas on the basis of regionalism.
After becoming a national figure , let us expect him to come forward for this issue also.
Regards
S.P.Singh
Mumbai
Bhai Amar singh g AAp ke blog me dekhta jroor hun padh kar accha bhi lagtha hai is blog me aapne jo prasn uthe hai ho shai nhi lagthe .Netha samaj ko netratva dhetha hai ho hamara aadrsh hota hai use buraiyo ke viruha sangrash karna aur janjagran karna chaiye na ki un buraiyyo me khud lipat ho jayi jinme smaj ke kuch hi log lipth hai .Btastachar yesa hi muddha hai . phale bhi nethaon ke pas dhan aatha hoga par ho us pese se samajik karya karthe aapne niji jindgi me nhi yha karan hai ki ram manohar lohiya, deen dhyal, rajnarain, lalbhadhur nheru, Atal ji ko aaj bhi aadarsh mana jathA HAI ,aaj bhi kyo aam janta modi,nitish ki prasaca karti hai
adarniya amarsinghji,
kahan antardhyan ho gaye the?….aisa prateet ho raha hai ki sp se nishkasan ke bad aap aprasangik ho gaye hain……aapke bayanon se lagta hai ki zald hi congress mein samil hone ka iraada kar liye hain………
मनोज जी आगे आगे देखिये क्या होता है?
Amarji,
Wonderful,with single CD you are targeting two, the politician ( Mr. Yadav) + The activist ( Lokpal Committee ).This is what distinguishes Amar Singh.
Regards
Vijay
yes I Agree with your blog Amar Singh ji but try to understand U.P. ka musalman and thakur aap ka bahut besabri se intezar ker reha ha ,,,,,,
congress me samil ho ker apni pachan khone ki koshis mat kerna…..you know waha aapka Sonia ji aur Rahul ji ka hi isharo pe nachna pdega…..jisme aapka wajud kho jaigea because you don’t know ki kitne log aapko apna Rajniti guru mante ha…wesa aapko advise dena aesa ha jesa suraj ko chirag dikhana…..
Your follower
Israr
(J.P.Nager) U.P.
because shar kuch bhi ho jai per kabhi ghas nhi khata
Sir apni apni soch hai
आदरणीय श्री अमर सिंह जी सादर चरण स्पर्श …
सर में स्वयं श्री अन्ना जी का बहुत सम्मान करता हूँ और भ्रष्टाचार के भी खिलाफ हूँ परन्तु सिर्फ राजनेताओं को टार्गेट करना गलत है , लग रहा है समाजसेवक और मीडिया राजनीती को अंडर-वर्ल्ड घोषित करने पे तुले है , समाज सेवक एक ग्राम या कस्बे की व्यवस्था तो चला सकते है परन्तु देश …….में आपके ब्लॉग के माध्यम से समाजसेवको और मीडिया से गुजारिश करना चाहूगा राजनीतिज्ञ जैसे सम्मानीय पद की प्रतिष्ठा को लेखन या किसी और माध्यम से धूमिल न करे यह देश के हित में अच्छा नहीं है !
धन्यवाद
Half of these people aboveseem to be using such a valuable forum to offer respects / praise for you.
A more representative sample of the general public’s sentiment can be accurately viewed in the comments section of everyday newspapers.
Dear sir, gud morning, kya rahul ganghi amul baby hain , kya aap sp main jaye ge , agar sp main aap jate hain tou sp ko nayi takat milegi ,
Dear Mr Amar Singh,
Well written article, and in the spirit of transparency and integrity which Mr Hazare is promoting I too have my concerns over the inclusion of Father-Son duo in the committee.
Bandook kitni bhi achi ho, Goli hona zaroori hai! I respect Mr Hazare for all he has done, but he needs to have the right men beside him.
And again, in a democracy how can ONE Anna Hazare recommend/dictate terms on such matters? All said and done, Ministers are the “Elected Representatives” of people in a democracy, who elected the members of Anna’s movement? Is the presence of 100,000 people or support for 500,000 representative of 1 billion people?
If the CD is a “Smear Campaign”, what about the blanket attack on “ALL” politicians by Mr Hazare? In true terms, that is also a “Smear Campaign” against honest politicians…maybe one such politician should file a Contempt case against him as well??
- Aurbind (Singapore)
Aurbind – I am glad you are based in Singapore and I hope you never come back to India. Good luck mate with a good, comfortable life in SG.
Shri Amar Singh Ji
Jai mata ji ki ……
Aapne jo new party banai hai { Rashtriya Lokmanch}
iskeliye bahut bahut badhai ho & me pure tan man dhan se apko & apki party ko samarthan karta hu……
Puran Singh Rathore S/O Madho Singh
V/p : Nagari
Teh. : Khinwsar
Dist. : Nagaur , Rajasthan
Mob. No. : 9413092203
Dear Amarji
A quote of Netaji Subash chandra Bose
Indian nationalism is inspired by the highest ideals of the human race, satyam (the true), shivam (the god), sundaram (the beautiful). Nationalism in India has… roused the creative faculties which for centuries had been lying dormant in our people.
Wooh”" what’s a punch!!!!!!!! Greeting for the same.
Actually we all corrupt……… may be people not agree with this….. but way we want all the advantage ??????????? for our self ????? a simple example of our selfishness our driving sense and way….. how cruel we are on the road.
Nothing will happen , because we all want lavish life superior and better then other.
Sorry if pinch .
pls do not distrub anna ji work…
Wooh.. You are at your best again Mr. Singh to prove political relevance knowing well that you are swimming against general sentiments.The reason why Politicians should take the blame for rampant corrpution is that you guys are running this country and dictating law of land and letting non-political class get submerged into thick of corruption. Please learn to take your fare share of blame belonging to same class called “Politics”.
I do follow your blog regularly but i am pained to see this blog…losing confidence to understand you better.
MR. Singh, not sure if you read these comments. But I am a simple man. I have 2 things to say:
- Why not support an effort instead of criticizing? Its like saying unless things align 100%, I will only criticize. Somebody has made a start. Do you think all corruption can be removed from all walks overnight? And till that happens nobody should even take the first step.
- For 2-3 days, every day, just spend 5 mts thinking when we all die, (I will; you will) what do we take with us. 70 or 80 years of life seems long but it goes pretty fast. Please do this honestly every day – even for 2-3 days. And then think about what our Soul or Atma will say to us on the last day of our life…HONESTLY SIR JI
I just went through this page (and your website) for the fisrt time. I must praise this one thing for sure: you reply to various comments, even if they are against you. A two way dialog is a must and you and your team seem to be one of the few in India who is at least trying.
Anna tto lagata hai kha gaye congress kko.?
क्या देश मे शांति भूषण और उनका बेटा ही रह गया था समिति मे नामित करने के लिये . अन्ना ने ये कृत्य कर लोगो के विश्वास को छला है . ये बात तो उसी दिन स्पष्ट हो गयी थी आखिर इतनी महत्वपूर्ण कार्य के लिये एक ही परिवार के दो व्यक्तियो को क्यो रखा गया कही न कही दाल मे कुछ काला है .लेकिन बाद के घटना क्रम ने साबित कर दिया कि ये तो पूरी दाल ही काली है. समिति की बैधानिकता पर तो न्यायालयो मे अलग से प्रश्न पूछे जा रहे है वो बात अलग है . लेकिन जिस नैतिकता के बल पर ये लड़ाई लड़ी जा रही थी उसे अन्ना के फैसले एक ही परिवार के दो व्यक्तियो को नामित कर कुठाराघात कर एक बड़ा पाप किया है .लोगो का विश्वास तोड़ा है ,लोगो के साथ छ्ल किया है. अन्ना के इस हट के जितनी निन्दा की जाय वो कम ही है
रूडी जी आप का लगता है सॉफ्टवेर आंड हार्डवेर दोनो गड़बड़ है1 तभी तो आप कुच्छ बोल नही पा रहे है1 जा के अच्छी तरह से बोलना सिख लो किसी प्राइमरी स्कूल मे !
ये अमर जी है जो बोल रहे है 1 ओ बाप बेँटो को तो फैशी दी जानी चाहिए ये ही देश के कालेधन के लीडर है!
Dear Mr. Amar Singh..whatever you say…but there is one truth that this country is suffering a lot due to the politicians who are running the country.Every person is suffering a lot due to their wrong doing.
Parvinder Kumar
parry.ism@gmail.com
RESPECTED AMAR SINGH JI,
GAMBHIR RASTRIYA MUDDO PER HALKI RAJNITI NAHI KERANI CHAHIYE.“बेगानी शादी में अब्दुल्ला दीवाना,KAB TAK BANEGE AAP
ऐसे मनमौजी को मुश्किल है समझाना. छमा कीजियेगा पर, जितना लोगो ने आपका इस्तेमाल किया, उससे कहीं ज्यादा आपने खुद अपना इस्तेमाल होने दिया | आज की गलतियाँ, आनेवाले कल का अनुभव बनती है | MAGAR AAP…अन्ना के समर्थक पूरी तरह ईमानदार है Amar Singh jee, your latest strategy seems to join the rising sun of UPA fold without directly entering Congress. Power-brokers are non-ideological personalities playing politics only for their personal benefits. Indian politics has turned for worst as compared to that of yesteryears when there was at least some input of ideology in politics with motto of serving to society. Now politics revolves around individuals where some regional politicians are grossly misusing politics for personal benefits rather than service for people.आपने इस आंदोलन की बखिया उधेर दिया है. अपना शुरू से यह मानना था कि यह आंदोलन केवल कांग्रेस के विरुद्ध जनाक्रोश के लिए सेफ्टी वाल्व का काम करने वाला है. अन्ना साहब के लिए निश्चय ही अच्छी भावना है मन में लेकिन कांग्रेस के घाघपन का वे शिकार हो गए हैं इसमें रंचमात्र भी संदेह नहीं है. गांधी की वैचारिक हत्या करने के बावजूद उन्हें बेच कर अभी तक कांग्रेस के घर की चुला जलाती रही है अब एक अन्ना भी मिल गए हैं शायद कांग्रेसियों को.
जहां तक संघ परिवार का सवाल है तो एक सस्ते फ़िल्मी डायलाग उद्धृत करना चाहूँगा मुझसे (कांग्रेस से ) लड़ने का जज्बा तो ले आओगे….’कमीनापन’ कहां से लाओगे…..–R.K.Singh [National Secretary] Akhil Bhartiya Kshatriya Mahasabha D-137/8 Indira Nagar Lucknow 9415544100
From:
Maheeb Maheeb maheebmaheeb@yahoo.com
SIR,
First on my objection against demand for Lok pal…. (Answer to your question is given at the end.)
1 – Is not Lok pal duplication of agencies?
a) There are many anticorruption mechanisms incorporated in our laws and regulations and there are many vigilance/anticorruption wings in each department. CVC was set up in 1964, as recommended by Santhanam committee, As found wanting, it was provided statutory status and more teeth in 1998 & 2003… all these to prevent corruption. Yet corruption had been unabatedly flourishing all through these years to engulf the most revered institutions of our society, namely Chief Justices of Supreme courts and the Commission itself (please recall Santhi/Prasant Bushan’s challenge and the recent controversy in CVC , P J Joseph & CIC appointments). How independent and useful would be a Joseph like CVC or Lok Pal?
2. b) There were/are umpteen NGOs striving with ant-corruption agendas. In early 2000s they (ADR & co) had been seeking RTI & CIC as a panacea against corruption with as much fervor as we see today for Local… And they got it too in 2005. can anybody tell me if corruption decreased after 2005 or increased?
There are some success in unearthing the information. and few have used to fight it against the corrupt. Some succeeded in it but many like Amit Jatwa) got brutally attacked and even murdered by the corrupt mafia with the connivance of their partner politicians. and ADR like proponents of RTI are using it to dig out information to tell us that quality our political leadership, elected representative have deteriorated since 2005 with more criminals and that too crimes of graver nature entering in the elections as candidates of political parties and getting elected to govern us!!!
So I think Lok Pal would just be another agency like CVC, CIC intended to prevent corruption… duplication. Proliferation of agencies is waste and a hindrance to optimal result… like the effect of proliferation of political parties in our politics, election and governance.
——————————-
2 – Sree. Anna Hazare himself, during a face to face talk with me in July 1996, had admitted that his success in ousting two corrupt ministers of Maharastra in1996 and his ‘Brastchar Virodhi andolan’ was not useful to control corruption, and had promised to take up exposure and rectification of the root cause of corruption… but he went back to continue the Brastachar Virodhi… and we all know, despite his struggles, corruption has not diminished a bit even in Maharastra… really it has grown to the Adhars housing scandal heights…
I do not know if any activists spearheading CVC demand in 1964 are still alive or not. But ADR like activists who fought for RTI are behind the Lok Pal, Anna’s fast & Dandi March too. I had been communicating with them on the futility of anticorruption activity till we understand and address the root cause of corruption as corruption is a symptom only.
But nobody has given me a reasonable answer to the questions I raised … or contradicted with logical arguments issues i raised. .. because, I presume, they do not have an answer… so many of them conveniently avoid me … Yet they do not stop their anticorruption agenda …
————————————————————————————————————————————–a glimps of Our analysis
1 – Almost all issues previously and presently fought by our reform activists are not the causes but just symptoms of our society’s degradation …
2 – Political leadership hierarchies with competent persons with character and integrity in all political parties (No parties are singled out… and not in Governments only) is a Prerequisite for better governance, reduced corruption and progress of the society.
3 – Primacy of ‘Inner party democratic competitions and elections’ in the internal functions of political parties to produce political leadership with above said virtuous qualities. ———————————
Now my accusation about Anna and the Bushan duo … seems to have proven by the facts getting revealed through the CD affair…
and i have a dout sir,what is the privillege to anna hazare to nominate 4 persons to committe of lokpal.i think this is an illegal privillege to hazare given by soniya gandhi..he is only an indian citizen like us..am i right sir.if u think so send me a mail.our organisation(GREAT INDIA TRUST)is going to file a pettission in supreme court aganist this illegal nomination power of hazare…we are waiting for ur great reply…
maheeb n. m
SIR,
First on my objection against demand for Lok pal…. (Answer to your question is given at the end.)
1 – Is not Lok pal duplication of agencies?
a) There are many anticorruption mechanisms incorporated in our laws and regulations and there are many vigilance/anticorruption wings in each department. CVC was set up in 1964, as recommended by Santhanam committee, As found wanting, it was provided statutory status and more teeth in 1998 & 2003… all these to prevent corruption. Yet corruption had been unabatedly flourishing all through these years to engulf the most revered institutions of our society, namely Chief Justices of Supreme courts and the Commission itself (please recall Santhi/Prasant Bushan’s challenge and the recent controversy in CVC , P J Joseph & CIC appointments). How independent and useful would be a Joseph like CVC or Lok Pal?
2. b) There were/are umpteen NGOs striving with ant-corruption agendas. In early 2000s they (ADR & co) had been seeking RTI & CIC as a panacea against corruption with as much fervor as we see today for Local… And they got it too in 2005. can anybody tell me if corruption decreased after 2005 or increased?
There are some success in unearthing the information. and few have used to fight it against the corrupt. Some succeeded in it but many like Amit Jatwa) got brutally attacked and even murdered by the corrupt mafia with the connivance of their partner politicians. and ADR like proponents of RTI are using it to dig out information to tell us that quality our political leadership, elected representative have deteriorated since 2005 with more criminals and that too crimes of graver nature entering in the elections as candidates of political parties and getting elected to govern us!!!
So I think Lok Pal would just be another agency like CVC, CIC intended to prevent corruption… duplication. Proliferation of agencies is waste and a hindrance to optimal result… like the effect of proliferation of political parties in our politics, election and governance.
——————————-
2 – Sree. Anna Hazare himself, during a face to face talk with me in July 1996, had admitted that his success in ousting two corrupt ministers of Maharastra in1996 and his ‘Brastchar Virodhi andolan’ was not useful to control corruption, and had promised to take up exposure and rectification of the root cause of corruption… but he went back to continue the Brastachar Virodhi… and we all know, despite his struggles, corruption has not diminished a bit even in Maharastra… really it has grown to the Adhars housing scandal heights…
I do not know if any activists spearheading CVC demand in 1964 are still alive or not. But ADR like activists who fought for RTI are behind the Lok Pal, Anna’s fast & Dandi March too. I had been communicating with them on the futility of anticorruption activity till we understand and address the root cause of corruption as corruption is a symptom only.
But nobody has given me a reasonable answer to the questions I raised … or contradicted with logical arguments issues i raised. .. because, I presume, they do not have an answer… so many of them conveniently avoid me … Yet they do not stop their anticorruption agenda …
————————————————————————————————————————————–a glimps of Our analysis
1 – Almost all issues previously and presently fought by our reform activists are not the causes but just symptoms of our society’s degradation …
2 – Political leadership hierarchies with competent persons with character and integrity in all political parties (No parties are singled out… and not in Governments only) is a Prerequisite for better governance, reduced corruption and progress of the society.
3 – Primacy of ‘Inner party democratic competitions and elections’ in the internal functions of political parties to produce political leadership with above said virtuous qualities. ———————————
Now my accusation about Anna and the Bushan duo … seems to have proven by the facts getting revealed through the CD affair…
maheeb n. m
thanks for this well concieved comment.
Hi Amar Singh Ji,
All the leaders, irrespective of their record, are elected for better governance by people. With this hope, when people observe the spread of corruption from top down approach due to some of these leaders, all the leaders as a community are labelled with such adjuctives. Any how these philosphy is applicable to all community take a example of all Sadhus. But real ones never bother.
As yonger brother, I also suggest you to focus & apply your constructive capabilities to our Eastern Uttarpradesh, where the level of corruptions are so strong that even it does not come out on surface. Eastern Uttarpradesh is due for every thing from all the Politicians for which they have been deprived for by Politicians. Proving this will be very simple in today’s context.
All the best. God bless us all.
A correction:
So only those are bothered with his statement who are dishonest towards their nation.
“sare neta chor hai” pata nahin par “sare chor neeta” to banate ja rahe hai ye saaf saaf dikh raha hai pichale kai saaloo se. kya congress , kya bjp aur kya bakii chunnu munnu …har kisi kee hawas hai satta chahe angootha daba kar ya gala daba kar… whatever you say but you cannot deny the fact that overall standard of indian politics has been gone down.. below any tolerance. kapil sibbal kehte hai ke lokpal kya karega, manmohan saahab mook darshak bane tamasha dekh rahe hai 3G ka , commonwelth ka , opposition congress ko bajane mai laga hai … “Sale sab ek doosare ko kose, aur desh chal raha hai ram bharose!!!”
??