When Ruchika Girhotra was assaulted by then Haryana police IG S.P.S. Rathore in Panchkula in 1990, we all were shocked. But that isn’t where this horrid tale ended! The innocent girl committed suicide 3 years later. Dear Ruchika’s life shouldn’t have ended like this. Now, 19 years later, the man responsible walks out of the court with a smile on his face and promising an appeal. Is this justice? Does Rathore only warrant “six months of rigorous imprisonment and a 1000-rupee fine” for destroying the life of an innocent girl and her family?
It has taken almost two decades for the Indian judicial system to produce a sentence for this criminal and the sentence has been announced based on Rathore’s old age rather than the fact that the girl was a minor. Rathore has all these years not only enjoyed elite government positions but has also been getting regular promotions. He was even made the director general of police in Haryana. Is it now time for the government at the center to look closely at the judicial system and make amends? 19 years later and still without justice, Ruchika Girhotra lost her life to a system not prepared to help her. How can we expect anyone else to believe in the system when we ourselves can’t trust it with our own problems?
As far as women empowerment is concerned, today India is leading the world with so many women holding top positions such as president of India, leader of the ruling political party, leader of opposition in Lok Sabha, and speaker of Lok Sabha. But these symbols of women empowerment need to ensure that women at the lowest level should also get their due share. I am the father of two growing up girls and can very well understand the ordeal that family members of Ruchika and Aarushi would have gone through. Ruchika and Aarushi are few cases which have come into light but there are 1000s of cases which go un-noticed. Only going for candle light processions and writing on a Blog is not going to be the solution we’re looking for, rather the problem has to be addressed at the depth of our social fabric. More stringent laws have to be made to ensure that such offenders don’t get away easily and punishments should work as warning to future potential offenders. We must get this message to these vile, criminal people.
Tags: Amar Singh Opinion, amar singh ruchika, ruchika case, why did ruchika die, women in india, women safety in india
SIR, IF YOU THINK THIS WRONG ENOUGH THAN THE SOLUTION ONLY HAVE LEADER WHO RESPRESENT ‘AMM ADAMI’.
Nice post! Can you use your political strength to help her family to get the justice?
Sir,
It is nice to see u blogging . It is very necessory for us to know your views about day to day social and political issues apart from whatever press is projecting.
It is shame for all of us that the eve teasing is still continue in our society it becomes more painful when such a big official foun involved in such cases. He should be punished publically and all his previous privilages provided by the government may be recoverd from his sattlement or from his property.
Mr Singh… I suppose you should be taking actions rather than spending time on blogs. I can’t even believe you have time to be sitting before computer and writing blogs rather. Indian system is flawed… and every politician that’s covered by media are the reason
who says amar singh is sitting on computer and posting these articles? don’t you know the level of english he has? this must be coming to his blogs without him even knowing it.
Hey Rajesh,
Can u make much clear what you want to say…need more information…
Thanks.
Mr Singh..i completely agree with the post by Bismillah, enough of time spend on words now time for action.How can someone who committed such a crime be left so easily??She and her family needs justice and if you really feel bad for her as your above blog indicates you have to give her justice very soon .
Shri Amarshingji,
Good of you to show your sensitivity at the plight of Ruchika and her family. I can only wish God give then strength to bear this pain.
Yes, our system is flawed. But is it because we do not have strong law or is it because we do not have strong implementation? I think we are poor on implementation. Combined that with out social tendancy to avoid conflict with anyone with Power and we have tragedies like Ruchika’s family!
Wish underfunded overburdened judiciary and police force, what could we expect but delays in court? e.g. We have ratio of available police per 100,000 people of only 130, compared with an international average of 270.
In Gujarat Mr Modi has added working time of courts by introducing night courts and he is trying to cut down this delays considerably. Mr Chidambaram has just yesterday announced expansion of police force.
I have admired your courage when your actions – in supporting Nuke deal – spoke loud. I fully understand that you can not solve every problem of our country.
However, it would be great if you could do something in terms of action – even from political angle as this is an issue that touch every Indian’s heart – by supporting Ruchika’s family and also in long term supporting some solutions that ensure there are no more such cases and delays in our society anymore.
Many thanks for raising this point in your blog and keep up your good work Sir.
why dont u do something about it. could be great if your SP could picket his house if the courts cannot deliver justice.
This canot continue any more. I shall put the number one governing party responsible for this kind of society we arrived at. This is because they adopted and encouraged all wrong doing just to be in power for ever. They are rulling for since independence except a few small halts and created this mess. They must be shamful for their forefathers’ creation of such ugly system,
Sh. Amar Singhji,
I completely agree with the views of Bismillah that the actions and not the words are the need of hour. We should not only ensure to see that the Rathore get severe punishment but also make it sure that the other officials who were involved with him must also be put to justice, particularly strict action should be taken against school administration which expelled Ruchika on baseless or false pretext.
In fact, we would be highly obliged if you lead the countrymen over such cause.
Sir, it is ok. but we want to only constraint on Developing State.
Sir
It is very nice that you paid attention and write on this matter.This is really very much humiliating and frustrating that even after 19 years the judgement will be considered as failure.This is really eye opener that we are helpless.This can be happen to anyone.
Very nice of your BLOGs, I m congratulation to u for BLOGs. u send his opening to public. Public will be give u a corner in his sweat heart.
Mr. Singh,
Enough has been told on the issue of Ruchika.If you politician are really for AAM ADMI,Then come out in open and challenge the injustice done to her award the culprit his due.Please lets not make it a media story and gather sympathy.Any act of yours will create a ray of hope and also the faith in judiciary and our beloved peoples representative like you whom we think our VOICE
I am seriously disturbed by reading this case. If this is the state of affairs in this country, I guess we actually deserve to be bombed by terrorists. I almost broke my laptop looking at the grin on that molestor’s and that woman’s face . How could he? Including the harassment part this is one of the worst crimes that I have read about, I would go on to compare it with the Shanda Sharer murder case where the guilty were handed over 60 years in prison. Maybe the law makers and enforcers don’t realize this, but this case requires exemplary punishment…it is serious morale buster.
It is really surprising to note that you pay your sincere attention to the injustice done to the pitiable girl amidst your mounting political commitments.I fully agree with you that the punishment given to the culprit is not at all enough .He should have been given life sentence.
If you can help her family financially and beat the shit out of that f******* police officer,I will vote for SP for all my life.
president of India=Naukrani
leader of the ruling political party=Making Money leader of opposition in Lok Sabha=chatter-box
speaker of Lok Sabha-Dumb
Aam Janta = Ram Bharose
Dear Sir,
Its heartening to see a leader of your stature writing about this issue. Shame on our society for letting the culprits walk scott free.
By writing in your blog you have shown solidarity with family and friends of the poor girl.
Keep up the good work of writing this blog. Hope other politicians learn something from you.
Dear Amarsinghji,
It is nice to see your blog and you discussed about Ruchika’s case. This is injustice, every common man in the country know it but they can not do anything about it other than just a protest. But you guys being our political leader should do something to change the laws which can support Aam Aadmi. So that Aam Aadmi start believing in our judicial system. The situation is really very bad. Mr. Singh, you know that in our country Aaam Aadmi afraid to go to court, they try to keep away from it. But the people with political & police contacts and with money enjoy the judiciary, they can buy witness, can change police report, can afford the high lawyer fees.
There were the politicians (one party or other), who promote Rathor to DG of Hariyana. God knows what else he has done with his power. You guys should do something about it, so that in future anyone would get a life time prison/death and no one think of doing it again.
आपका ब्लॉग तो शानदार है साब!… लेकिन अंग्रेजी की जगह अगर हिंदी में होता तो आम लोगों (जो इन्टरनेट का उपयोग करते हैं!) को भी समझ में आता और आपकी लोकप्रियता पर चार चाँद और लग जाते!…
शुभ भाव
राम कृष्ण गौतम
Definitely the punishment is insignificant for such a grave crime. People take advantage of some lapses in the law. We should have better laws to deal with such crimes. WE do not have deterrent laws to deal with such crimes. It is true that the culprit coming out of the court shamelessly stating that he would go for appeal. But as a whole the functioning of courts is good. At least we are get some justice, though sometimes very late and it no way serves any purpose.
Amar Singh ji, I am a regular on your elder brother’s blog and today I got to know from there that you have also started blogging! I hope to get a chance to interact personally with you through this medium, and I hope that you will take time out from your busy schedule to reply to comments posted here too.
Your blog raises some very valid issues, but I have a question for you – Why do people like Rathore escape? Because our politicians support them, and you also know that which family in Haryana’s politics has been sheltering Rathore.Shouldnt action taken against them too for protecting and promoting a man accused of such a heinous crime?
Singh Sahib
Its good to see you blogging. I have been Mr AB’s blog reader from 20th day he started blogging. I agree with your blog. I disagree some reader saying you shouldn’t spent time on computer – how one spend his/her private time is no one’s business. This can be a good tool to spread awareness or express opinion or bond with people.
You should now ensure justice is done to the family. That guy got off so easily. What a shame !!
Merry Christmas to you and your family.
Regards
Rajendra Negi
Nice see your blog…Let me read all then i will comment
We love you Sir.
Congrats Amar Singh Ji
उत्तर प्रदेश असोसिएशन औफ़ उत्तर अमेरीका
भाषा ही जोड़ती है
http://www.upana.org
Uttar Pradesh Association of North America
Language Unites US
http://www.upana.org
Thank You for starting a Green blog
Maybe PAA be an inspiration …
Bay Area Indo American
Wishes you the Best
and
Welcomes You
paa reached 39 countries/territories and much more … counting …
Real honor for India and Everyone …
http://www.bayareaindoamerican.com/events/paa
****************************************************
Dear Amar Singhji,
Nice to see you enter the BLOG world, I read about your blog, on Amitji’s blog and immediately decided to visit it. Your post about this sensitive subject is very relevant and I hope all politicians think like this, if politicians don’t support corrupt and arrogant officers like Rathore then they wont have courage to do anyting like this. Please try your best to give this family justice.
Dhanyawad,
Vinay Thakur
**************************************************
Very thoughtful writing.
However, I do not have any trust in politicians (with due respect to you). Wasn’t Rathore given political patronage even after his heinous crime? Were not all the politicians aware of this case for last 20 years? Why is suddenly each politician coming in defense of Ruchika now, after Rathore got a petty justice?
Dear Mr Singh,
Hope reading your blogs will change my opinion on Indian politicians. My sympathies are with Late Ruchika’s parents.Hope the perpertrator of this crime will roast in hell. I only hope that you have not taken to politics for personal gains
Sir, Nice to see u blogging. Thanx to Amitji who has given us the reference of your blog. AmarSinghji, something has to be done sooner than latter on the judicial system of the country. See, everyone knows that the culprit will escape again as he is prepared for an appeal. The bottom line is that it gives a very bad example to the society and encourages more such cases in the near future. These people knows that power can do anything in India…..enjoy it and if at all got accused or caught, by that time they will be in the twilight stage of life or even dead…as a case takes decades and decades to solve in India.
Hi Amar,
Firstly, congratulations to you web site – It is a really goo initiative.
We are regular visitors to Anthony’s (Mr Bachchan’s) blog and he guides us to visit your this site. We are great fan of Big B, so would like to suggest some points of improvements of your web-site. Please see if it’s feasible for you to consider
1. There is too much of political stuff on this site and your blog contents. While it’s obvious as you are a political leader, It would be a good idea to include non-political stuff like education, entertainment, general life, a little scientific, fun things. This would interest and encourage the people to be consistent visitorand follower in tern.
2. You could get a good idea on contents from Mr. Bachchan’s blog. His contents and bog flavour is superb that automatically generates interest in the reader.
3. Other this is Big B doesn’t always write about films, he select practical topics and writes on variety of things. This make his Blog #1 and catches the eyes of everyone.
4. Big B also interacts with his fans and actually responds to them. You may eventually practice the same.
5. Mig B also invites opinion of other through a poll. This could also be a great idea for you.
The above are just of thoughts for improvements and in general the this site is very good initiative from you on insistent fro Mr. Bachchan.
All the best and Regards
Dolly & Mukesh
Dear Sir,
Ruchika is not a single girl who did it, i think a number of girls is facing same problem. Now Indian govt. should take a some bold step against ex-IPS. Govt. should amend in rules.
Thanks.
Dear Amar Singhji,
It does not sound good that you are talking about the system and ruchika.
Who created this system…who made this system….you politicians…are to be blamed for it, for your selfish interest you can go to any extent….ruchikas sucide should have been eye opener to you…think of the father and brother the torture they had to go thru last 19 years… instead of writing blog you shud use your influence to have this DGP hanged publically at India gate..so that no powerful person can think he can d what ever he wants and pass away with 6months prison sentence..wondering the judge who gave this sentence…didnt he feel even ashamed of it…a rotten system with corrupt judiciary….
Dear Sir,
At the outset, Hearty Congratulations for starting your blog and website. I think it is very pertinent in today’s world for a dynamic leader such as yourself. I also take this opportunity in Wishing You and Your Family – A Very Happy, Healthy and Peaceful Christmas and A New Year.
I absolutely agree with your view that justice should be fast and furious for such offenders to set an example, especially if they are public servants. Could you please table a bill in the parliament for getting the most severe punishment for public servants.
Our motherland needs more leaders like yourself. Sir, I would be very delighted if solar electricity projects are pushed for in all the rural areas.
Please continue the goodwork.
Warm regards.
Arun
Its all very well to blog Mr Singh but i havent seen you on TV commenting on this case, sorry these people are not jaya pradhas or the bachans, but they are ordinary indians. Or are you scared Chutala will break your legs!!
Mr. Amar Singh,
Ruchika’s whole family disturbed due to this
incidence his brother was unemplyed, his father lost the job they were financially unsound.
Their family position financially and socially is very sombre after 19 yrs.
The only flaw is ‘OUR SYSTEM’ this the time to change the system.
If you realy have some pain in your heart for Ruchika, the only question I put in front of your now what your are doing for her family ?
Now what you are doing ? you are a industrialist also would you help ruchika financially ? or you will only be a part of this dirty politics Mr. Amar Singh…………….
Dear Amarsinghji,
I am Your fan not because of your politics but because of your friendship with Amitji, the way you maintain your relationship with your friends is what really touched me.
I am just visting your site as my favorite Mr. Big B requested his EFs to do so on his blog.
All the best to you Mr. Singh
Regards
Suhel Farooq Rehmany
It is nice to read ur blog…both urs and Big B’s…Yes..true friends are those that stand through with you through thick n thin…….as u can see we are ur fans too coz u have an amazing friend like mr amitabh bachchan….wish u a long lkife and a very happy new year…
Dear Amar Singhji,
I watched your interview the other day a personal memory down the lane. It was nice may be less of politics.
I stumbled upon this blog of yours and I feel really happy that you have taken the case of Ruchika in your blog.
If there are people like you to lend their voice against the mighty and powerful then we can for sure make it happen.
Will keep in touch with your blog…
Senthilkumar
I agree the system needs to be tighter and foolproof. As such molestation cases such as these are not uncommon- normally no one complains. pata hai kuch naheen hoga.beizzati hogi, barbadi hogi. And for this man too, he seems a lech-he must have a history- how come no one else complained? How did he get away for so long?
A few more cases like these and people will take law in their own hands.
Hello Amarsinghji, it very nice view on your ruchika case. i should go jail whole life give him fine 1 core that amount give to ruchika family and her friends. I m your fan b’coz your good friends of Amitji. plz u support him alwas & do some think about who divided our country base of langauge and place. Thanks
Dear Amar da,
The Ruchika Girhotra case has been making headlines only recently. But where were the media, politicians and so called woman organisations since 1990. Many of us didn’t even know about Ruchika till only a few days back.
The country wants to board the gravy train (term used more often in South Africa) so as to give vent to their common thread of thinking.
British Politician William Gladstone said, ‘Justice delayed is Justice denied’
The circumstances leading to SPS Rathore’s imprisonment has never been made clear. As an Orthopaedic Surgeon who deals with Forensic Medicine in my everyday life, Mr. Rathore’s involvement with Ruchika has never been proved in the strictest sense which the legal system wants.
Why there was no furore over the Professor Papiya Ghosh murder case in Patna where her eyes were gouged out befor multiple stabbing.
Nobody took notice when the sentences were passed and the main culprit, a politician is still at large.
Amarda, it’s good that you have encouraged the common thread of sympathy and outrage by your blog but unfortunately that would end at just this point.
Regards
Amitabh
85 year old Andhra Governor, Narayan Dutt Tiwari caught in sex scandal. Check the video in telugu with images -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OegTOBNK1fs
Hi Amar singhji, got to know about ur blog through AMITJI.Though i am ur fan but in few subject i am going to grill you.LETS start with ruchika case, all u politicians are father also(plz dont forget)lets see what can u do with that f*#king culprit.SUNIL
Dear Amar Singhji,
Welcome to Blogosphere.Your recent illness,your outburst against your party after lost elections in UP & your sudden ir-relevance in contemporary national & state poltics has pushed you to change your hat & u r trying to create a thakur constituency through ThakurAmar singh.com! Intelligent move indeed.Welcome politcian Amar Singh.Your joining the chores & Whipping up Ruchika case is nothing but to look & remain contemporary.
When will you come out of hyde?
Thanks sir…nice blog..
would appreciate if it has a more national touch rather than political…
I wish we should not have got independent. By independence who benifited? only politician more importantly one family!
Sirji,
I understand your feelings regarding Arushi and Ruchika and their families as you are also a father of girls. But there is a difference. We and the above two girl’s families are normal people. We are told that we have strength to vote. But what strength we have you also know that. W
omen empowerment, delay in justice all is good to say but when it comes to individual politician or authority holders its just what they want. Girls in UP and Haryana everyday face molestations. What language our Police dept use we all know. And what language you people use that also we know. I remember Mayawati’s statement on girl’s rape.
What we expect form leaders is not to (just) write blogs but to take action and help families, people, citizens of India by making changes in laws and fight corruption and political pressures in such cases. Help them if you can, we are requesting you because you are here o/w in today’s India leaders are just photos in papers and videos on TV. They are not really available. Thanks
Shri Amar Singh Ji,
Please use your political power to ensure that Adarneeya Shri Madhu Koda Ji gets decorated with Bharat Ratna.Adarneeya Geeta Koda ji and Guruji Shibu Soren should get ATLEAST PadamaVibhushan.Sir,please do something about this.You can do it because you are my only hope.
Aam Janta
Dear Amar Singhji,
It is good to see you making a comment on this issue and showing concern for the aggrieved party. I would really really appreciate if you can continue to show your concern about this matter and follow it up with some action (in parliament etc)till some semblance of real justice is done. You know, you have the power to do it, whereas most others on this board (myself included) can only comment and show our concern.
Thank you very much
Hello Mr. Singh,
This is not an issue to be discussed on blog as this would lead to no conclusion. We all would have to agree that Mr. Rathore was at fault and he should have been punished but can we decide this on blogs? No we are just wasting our time and energy discussing this. If you really have concern about her and her family, a public litigation should be filed asking Legal system and Government of India about the insensitive behaviour and attitude towards this case.
These cases bound us to rethink about our police and legal system and its flaw.
Anyways, lets end this discussion here.
Regards,
Siddharth
Dear Sir,
It is heartening to know that you have started your blog. We can discuss various social issues. I disagree with Bismillah that politicians should not blog. Why not? It is an opportunity for them to listen to Aam Admi through the blog.
Sir apart from Ruchika case there are many girls who are harassed by their teachers. Some small school boys and girls are beaten by their teachers and have to face death. I will very soon initiate an agenda to create awareness about this. I wish to get your expert views on how I should go about this issue.
Regards
Suchitra
I am sure it is just a matter of time before real justice catches up with that Rathore. Thanks a lot to the media. It is time to redeem.
This proves that this is INDIA ,Mera Bharat Mahaan.This is not first time this is happening but it happens usually in India.
“P” for Politicians and “P” for Paisa.
Mr Amar Singh,
I surely believe that no politician does any thing without a motive… and I mean None !.. You can prove me wrong by taking upon yourself Ruchica’s case and take it to it’s logical end.. It will not add to your vote bank,but for sure add respect among common middle class Indians… Shall be watching your actions closely… How about using ‘bade bhaiya’ to bring in little more seriousness !!!
Rakesh
I am really happy with Media that brought this case up now for justice of Ruchika case.Thanks to Media once again.It was ashamed for HC to grant such a light punishment to culprit ,i think the judges dont have any heart ,or they dont have daughters at home,that make them feel ashamed.if such incidence is happened with them,i think then only they would get some lesson.
Dear Amar Singh ji,
You sound just like any other media report. We already have way far too many Electronic and Print media channels to know what has happened, and your additional commentary does not contribute anything more.
Are you trying to garner the support of the readers. Isn’t that the masses should look forward to you and expect you to fight for this case. If you really feel what you have written, we expect you take up the issue at the highest level and fight for it and talk later.
Regards
Weel spoken Sir
Dear Amar Singh Ji,
I am sure you are aware of how manupalative our politicians can be. They have both power and power makers by their side + the short memory of indian’s is well known.
In case u as a leader wants to prove a point why dont you act upon the issue rather than just making it an issue..? It makes more of a gossip then an issue to me.
We indians dont need gynan. we need action..
The question faced today by the Nation is how will we bring back the lost glory of our ethical and moral value system that we enjoyed and inherited in the past ages from our forefathers and the cultural gurus and protectors of the moral schools in our part of the World.
Who is really to be blamed for the abuse and misuse of power, contact and money in the case of Ruchika, she gave her life not withstanding the agony and failure to beat the system and power of a ruthless and manipulative powerful officer on duty Rathode.
She suffered three years of unbearable agony and abuse, with her family shattered and fragmented, asking for justice running from pillar to post, the several social and community bodies supporting her and raising her plea with the authorities of the time failing to get speedy justice for her and her family.
If this is case with the victim supported advocated so strongly gets raw deal by our system, then we know what will the fate of the thousands out there struggling for justice in some form or the other in our wide nation.
The root to this is deeper, the society we are in today is to be blamed, our ethical and moral system has suffered most, we the people are not truly concern about what happens around us, we are not ready to challenge the system most of the time we surrender to the system run by the powerful and wealthy, surrendering this will not change and nothing can be done to it, we shelve our thoughts and get along with our routine.
We need to inculcate, values, respect our being human beings, and learn to grow as good sensible, and protective people who can raise to the occasions and be brave and assertive to drive fear in the detractors, and manipulators of law, and degrades of our society.
We have bad to very bad examples to be worried about, we are see and hearing every day on our neighbourhood, in our city, in our print and electronic media. The lessons are not learned it is apparent.
How many more Ruchikas and families like her, need to pay the price and suffer before the system changes.
Who are the real culprits. Can we say we are not part of the problem, with great concern for our future as a nation, I am afraid we can’t.
It is really one of the saddest moment of our polity. A perverted and power drunk man could sabotage and subvert the system to hide his heinous act and our system could not stop him despite efforts/protests/submission to the custodians of polity of that time.
Only reason why such persons survive or escape because some of them have their masters who indulge and probably encourage them for their own advantage.
Please sir, ensure that this man gets the exemplary punishmen.
To be true, we Indians have become immune to injustice by now so this is not a surprise to me. Why we have to wait for another Ruchika or Jessica to happen? This is absolutely not acceptable. But then I believe, leaders like you can make a lot of difference by helping common people. I look forward to your say on this issue of woman empowerment in India.
RES TAKUR G NAMSTEY,
IT IS GOOD BLOG BUT HATS OFF FOR HER FRIEND ANURADHA PARENTS THOSE WHO GAVE A SUPORT IN ALL TIME.
THANKS AND REGARDS
TAKUR DEEPAK KATHAIT
salam walekum singh saheb, bahut khushi hui aapko internet ki dunia main dekh kar ,
singh saheb sach baat to yeh hai aap politicans kuch bhi kahe ya samjhe, lekin IPS N IAS jo biradri hoti hai na woh na kisi ki suntai hai na kisi ko kuch samjhati hai , ye wo log hai inko jo karna hai wahi karte hai . koi bhi CM ya PM bane IAS n IPS lobby ko jis dharre n nirunkushta k sath chalna hai wo usi par chalene.
so in short this is nt the question of Mr rathore or ruchika , this is question of failure of adminsitrative and police system in india.
The entire India is aghast at the power of one man who has been able to subver the entire political, judicial, adminstrativesystem in the country with impunity and getting out of the mess he got himself into. First question:What was he an IPS officer doing as secretary of a tennis association? Do politicians protect any bureaucrat without quid pro quo? If he has been protected for 19 years even after retiring from service what hold did he have on the politicians/ruling party (whichever it may be)? If people like you do not throw your weight and ensure this man is brought to book people will lose whatever remaining faith on the politicians.
The missionary are the real educational implementers throughout the world. It is these missionary and there counterpart who promoted education to all religion, community without fearing for there life and property they are the true promoters of education The time and immortal all gurukuls and the great visionary all contributed to the field of education but it was limited to a particular community and religion. Even the great guru Dronacharya was no exception for this the story of Eklavya can be quoted here. In Ruchikas case how come such a great mission school felt trap to bureaucrats diction. Instead of supporting the student they supported ill motivated and corrupt state official. This school not only brings shame to the mission and its ideology but they proved with the time that they too are here to earn money and fame. The time is not ripen take action against the school authority and bring them to the course of law. The punishment should be so severe in future no school or its official should dare to commit such a heinous crime.
v.suryanarayana
41 ABC TOWER NEAR ITWARI TEL.EXC.CA.NAGPUR
9373103377
Well said Suryanarayanji
u are my hero dear
Dear Mr. Amar Singh,
A friend of mine from UAE sent me your blog details. Re Ruchika Girhotra it is a sad case of snuffing out a talent and a travesty of justice. I happened to watch the Barkha Dutt show on Ruchika on NDTV. The most offending person I heard on that show was Ram Jethmalani. I was fuming more at him than at that animal ‘Rathore’ with his comments and his assessment of the case. I have even gone on record to say on our website that I would want to slap him right across his face, irrespective of his age, if I had a chance to be on that show. I have nothing but contempt for him and his ilk because all he does is use his expertise of the law to set free criminals who would be otherwise strung high to kingdom come.
Cheers
floriano
goasuraj
9890470896
http://www.goasu-raj.org
PS: Keep the fight against the monumental lady going.
PPS: Goa’s Need of the Hour……… What’s Zat???
HELLO;everybody,
I think the SAUDI ARABIA criminal law is best, that is the reason that it has less criminal records when compaired to the rest of the world
1. My guess is that this Rathore will get away this time too, by bringing in one or the other legal hurdle. Did it really require 19 years to solve this crime? What an agony the Girhotras had to go through all these years. Hats off to this young woman Aradhana who relentlessly persued this all these years.
Mr Amar Singh,
Is not it true that people at your sphere ( not necessarily you )are totally corrupted and rotting the core of the system. It is you people who are “elected” leaders and set worst example in every phases.
Lesson should be “straighted up thyself”.
Anyway, I don’t live in India – left it for my own good(otherwise may have end up on the wrong side of road) so just my 2 cent for other whoever is staying there.
Dear Mr. Singh:
Probably you might not be able to answer this. Do you know Dawood Ibrahim. How close is he with Indian politicians. How much control does he have on Indian Intelligence Apparatus.
yes Joe, you are right I can not answer this question. Like most of us all I know about Dawood that he had his roots in Azamgarh district of Uttar Pradesh. If I was ever part of Home department of Govt of India, probably i could respond to later part of your question.
Sir ,
Don’t get me wrong.
Why was no pressure exerted then for a speedy trial – when the case came up for hearing first @ 1990
- when she committed suicide after 3 years of the sorry incident – 1993/4
Why there was a collective silence on the lethargic pace of the legal process ?
Meantime the Cops received all honours only short of being Knighted !!
To my mind this is a wake up call.
Leaders cutting across party lines who represent the citizens of the country should take the lead position in bringing to focus the agonising pace of such and similar cases which are socially sensitive and highly violating of all moral and civil sense.
Would like to hear your views on this please
It has happened
What can we do to cause it not to happen again ??
Mohan
The whole police system is corrupted, even though we all know this why no politician for all these years did not do anything. How many traffic police persons are collecting the money for traffice offences and giving receipt properly. If a person makes a mistake in a private company he is thrown, the same should be implemented in governament offices. If you do not do this these police/lawyers will find loop holes and escape. Save the country.
Respected Amar Singh JI
The reaction of your party to the introduction of womens reservation bill in the parliament is known to all of us.When it comes to real positive action for empowering the women you people stop the proceedings of the House for long periods of time.
Does it really help by sheding tears now for the hapless families.Do something ,Sir,for Gods sake arise and join hands forgetting party affiliations to change the laws and the law dispensing agencies before the peoples power gets going.
its a matter of great concern.almost5000 kids commit suicide in our country every year we really need to be sensitive to the issues of the children.people who are in power always misuse power its really commendable that you have raised the issue,the media is with you always……
The entire system wasted time for 19 years..Now another leader wasting his time by writing blogs.
Wake up Amar Singh. You belong to the most backward state in terms of education,infrastructure and other basic amenoties. Why dont you work for the common man rather than going to bollywood parties and meeting Bacchans…Prove that atleast you are not power oriented…Wake up
bakerI am happy that after Ruchika’s case the government has woken up and appears determined to prosecute Rathore. However, had it done this 19 years back, Ruchika would have been alive.
Amar Singhji, I would seek your active help in ensuring that:
1. Rathore is actually booked and the case brought to it’s logical conclusion. It should not happen that the actions being initiated are a white wash due to the media flare up.
2. All those who collaborated with Rathore should also be brought to book. They should be immediately suspended and cases booked against them. One Rathore could not ahve done so much, had he not had othet police officers waiting to help him.
I am happy that after Ruchika’s case the government has woken up and appears determined to prosecute Rathore. However, had it done this 19 years back, Ruchika would have been alive.
Amar Singhji, I would seek your active help in ensuring that:
1. Rathore is actually booked and the case brought to it’s logical conclusion. It should not happen that the actions being initiated are a white wash due to the media flare up.
2. All those who collaborated with Rathore should also be brought to book. They should be immediately suspended and cases booked against them. One Rathore could not ahve done so much, had he not had othet police officers waiting to help him.
Dear Sir,
Really appreciate a letter from the top leader from India Mr Amar singh supporting for Ruchika’s family.Now he has to take his poitical power to get justice for her brother & father for years one cruel criminal was playing with his power to destroy a minor girl who did against sexual willingness.Court only thinking about his age, for giving small punishment and not thinking about the minor age for Ruchika & her brother. How can the people from India can trust to the court & Judge. Hope the judge will not support the evil in future( Rathore).
i was happy to know aboutyour resgnination from sp party. i would advice you to help in need and indeed those who require it. this reminds me of dushyant kumar’s shair’ dosto ab manch mein suvidha nahin hain, ajkal naipayta me samhawana hainso keep it up take care of your health.
Dear Amar Singhji,
I respect the decision taken by you.It is no doubt that the party is losing such a dynamic and inteligent leader like you. You have crated your own identity in the Indian politics.
Take care of your family and health.
respected mr amar singh ji
your personality does not need any position. whatever decision you have taken we all of us with you
wishing you all the best
regards
dr subhash chandra
Why you are not fighting for Ruchika’ justice?
There are crores and crores Ruchikas in India who are suffering from this worst ever socio-economic and political system . When I read about Ruchika and her family`s sufferings , I am solaced that I am not alone sufferer of this system .
I was selected as Tehsil welfare officer and I joined at Taran Tarn which is now a district head quarter in (Punjab)in Febuary ,1976.But my services were terminated without any reason and notice when I was doing my job at Patti after being transfered from Amritsar . I was a regular employee as per the then Parkash Singh Badal government .
I decided to challenge the dismissal order in the Pb. & Haryana High court .In the mean time , I phoned my real uncle / tayya ji ( Master ) Khushi Ram ji , Deputy chief controller of import and export in the union M/o commerce who was once the deputy secretary of the union public service commission .He immediately asked the director , welfare department , Punjab government to explain the reason of dismissal . Mr. J.S. Kesar IAS who was also sc by caste could not reply satisfactory and he had to reinstate me and I joined at Sirhind against a vacate post .
But I did only three months job and I left that job to enter in the social work as well as business of marketing in a company .My uncle was annoyed at this .The he retired and he persuaded me to accompany him to settle in Canada but I decided to live in India , for India .
My marketing bussiness was flourished and my company advanced for a car after three years of joining .In the meanwhile , I applied for a one kanal plot in the urban estate , phase 2 , Jalandar City .My plot was resumed due to political reasons .I received the resume order dated 10th September , 1989 when I deposited some amount on 9th September . The resume order was signed in Febuary , 1989 . Why the resume order posted after seven months ? They wanted a big amount as bribe but I refused .
I appealed to the head of the Urban estates at Chandigarh but she save her corrupt SC officer and I was denied justice . This plot costs Rs.two crores at the present market rate. Even my earnest money was not refunded till date.
Before this I started a Punjabi monthly magazine the Kaumi Udarian which was very popular .The politicins were affraid of its policy to awaken the people and they forfeited its Punjab problem special issue of July , 1986 and imposed TADA 3/4 and 153IPC on me .
I contested the Punjab assembly election from Jalandar North as BSP candidate in 1992 A.D. The DSP incharge of the area threatened me not to contest . I complained against him to the then SSP .But he was also part and parcel of this conspiracy .S. Beant singh , who became CM of Punjab was contesting from my residential Jallandar Cantt. assembly area.I was alloted 32 CRPF and fourPunjab police personnels for safety from terrorists !
When Sahib Kanshi Ram`s clash with the press happened on 25th October , 1996 , I was invited by him on 3rd November at Delhi to start a Punjabi weekly .I was conferred the resident editorship and it was launched by Sahib Kanshi Ram on 16th November , 1996 in a big BSP rally at Ludhiana .Its circulation was twenty five thousands for free distribution among BSP cadre .It was very popular due to my editorial talents . This bulletin was in direct contrast with the Punjab`s press . The top most Punjabi daily lost its sixty five thousands circulation .I reproduced the article of his father of the then editor of this daily which claimed that Dr. Ambedkar sanctioned the news paper quota for that news paper .This article exposed the news paper for criticizing a political party carrying the banner of Dr. Ambedkar.
This bulletin was the election period but I decided to continue it at a price of Rs. two after the election with a circulation of at least one lac .This horrified the BSP`s Punjab leadership and the entire press .They plotted a road accident to finish me on the assembly election day when I was covering the election i.e 7th Febuary , 1997.My two lietinaunts were killed and I was among six seriously injureds .
There was extreme when our statements were not recorded by the police.The police submitted a fake statement of mine in the court .This statement was by Chuni Lal Chumber when my name is Charanji Lal@ Chirinjeev Lal Chumber .My address was recorded as Mith pur road , Jalandar City when my address is 47-A, Dada Nagar , Model Town , Jalandar City .I told the judge that this is a conspiracy to kill me and to save the culprits .The honourable judge was angered at this and he urged me to unfold the names of the culprits .I named 15 culprits out of them one is present BSP`s Rajya Sabha member from Punjab , another ex BSP MP of Lok Sabha ,ex BSP MLA , ex congress minister against whom I contested assembly election in 1992 A.D.,an ex BSP leader who is now a chairman of a finance corporation , anothe ex BSP leader who is now a member of Punjab service selection board ,managing editor of a Punjabi daily , two BSP inclined writers total 15 .
The culprits got transfered the suitable judge to dismiss this court case .On November 13 , 2009 , I visited the court premises at Phagwara courts to have the copy of the court judgement .My advocate said that that case had been the dust . I asked him that why he did not informed about the judgement . He did not replied . What will be done to these advocates ?
c.l.chumber@gmail.com
thakur amar singh sahab aadab!
jo politics aaj kal ho rahi hai uska perbhav yuva pidi per kya padega aap log tau chahte hai ki yuva aage aaye lekin itni gandi politics main kya koi apna bhavishya dekhega .
kya mujhe es sawal ka jawab mil payega.
junaid husain
firozabad
Aishwarya also want to know why she died like this, she loves u Amar a lot.
Please help her to get the answer that why this happend to her?
Amar Singh Ji
Pranam!!!!!
I partially agree with bismillah..altghough beurocrats should be busy in smooth running of the country rather then blogging,but at the same time its only experssion of thoughts; openion and grief over any issues through media be it print or electronic; whcih ignites nation wide wave in or against any issue, and fatches justice.
I wish entire nation unites against such bitter and grusome acts.
Amarji, your partner of Netaji so your not aamAdmi, we all are. Our daughters and mothers goes hrough all this shyt not your…Please let us know are do you consider yourself as aamAdmi or superior/above aamAdmi?
Something I like abt you make me keep visiting this site. I wish you good luck for your health.
Having been a part of the Online Universal Work Marketing team for 4 months now, I’m thankful for my fellow team members who have patiently shown me the ropes along the way and made me feel welcome
http://www.onlineuniversalwork.com
Respected Mr Amar Singh Ji,
It is great to know that apart of your health and other political hazards you are thinking of AAMADAMI. I think some corrupt politicians and police personals are harassing AAMADAMI…
Dear Amar singh
Thanks for ur interest in this pls do some thing what you can do
Thanks
Nice post sir ji
DearTh.Amar Singh ji,
Firstly, congratulations to you website and constructive blogging
Its heartening to see a leader of your stature writing about this issue. Shame on our society for letting the culprits walk scott free.Definitely the punishment is insignificant for such a grave crime. People take advantage of some lapses in the law.
This is character of Kshatriya Samaj we never defend people Rathore.Though another caste people protect our people at any cost
All the best and Regards
DearTh.Amar Singh ji,
Firstly, congratulations to you website and constructive blogging
Its heartening to see a leader of your stature writing about this issue. Shame on our society for letting the culprits walk scott free.Definitely the punishment is insignificant for such a grave crime. People take advantage of some lapses in the law.
This is moral character of Kshatriya Samaj we never defend people like Rathore.Though another caste people protect our people at any cost
All the best and Regards
– R.K.Singh [National Secretary] Akhil Bhartiya Kshatriya Mahasabha MAIL-ksbisen@gmail.com.@gmail.com.secretaryabkshatriya mahasabha.R.K.Singh D-137/8 Indira Nagar Lucknow 9415544100
[...] Why did Ruchika have to die – Amar Singh [...]
Amar Ji
It is very nice that you paid attention and write on this matter.This is really very much humiliating and frustrating that even after 19 years the judgement will be considered as failure.This is really eye opener that we are helpless.
It is very nice that you paid attention and write on this matter.This is really very much humiliating and frustrating that even after 19 years the judgement will be considered as failure.This is really eye opener that we are helpless.
Dear Sir,
I Like your Opinion.
Thanks
Dear Amar Singh Ji,
Wish you and your family a happy,healthy & prosperous New Year 2011.
You were on a padyatra for one month.We were expecting some blog about yr experiece after completion of Padyatra.
Can We expect it ?
Regards,
Lalit Bhardwaj